Adult Children of Divorce -- Breaking the Cycle and Achieving Success
in Love, Marriage and Family. By Edward W. Beal, M.D. and Gloria Hochman,
Delacorte Press, 1991.
Article by Richard Crouch, Attorney at Law,
Crouch & Crouch, Arlington, Virginia; (703)
528-6700;
Originally Published in Family Law News, a Va. State Bar Publication,
Spring 1991
Family Law || Crouch
& Crouch Main Page
[Disclaimer: Items are not to be considered legal advice or to create
any lawyer-client relationship. Most articles include some obsolete information.
In addition, taking any legal information out of context, i.e., using it
in a different court or a subtly different kind of case, or without the
training to understand all of what it means or doing research to verify
it, usually has disastrous consequences.]
Probably all of us as divorce lawyers would say that this book
focuses on an area where much insight is needed. The authors are a Washington,
D.C. psychiatrist and his co-therapist. Dr. Beale is the psychiatrist whose
testimony proved so persuasive to the Court of Appeals in MED v. JPM, 3
Va. App. 391, 350 S.E. 2d 215 (1986).
And the insights are here: just about all of them. After spending a large
section of the book describing divorce itself and its impact on families
and children, the authors address such topics as "growing up faster,
when children and parents switch roles, the anxieties of courtship, "Are
you behaviorally mature?", and "Safeguarding your marriage."
Of course one section of the book is entitled "Breaking the Cycle."
Beal and Hochman's main concentration is on describing the problem, but
that description is accomplished in very alarming, if familiar, terms. The
authors point to studies that indicate one child in every ten will see his
or her parents divorce, experience one remarriage, and go through the parent's
second divorce all before age 16. They note that for 1989, there was still
approximately one divorce for every two marriages -- indicating that a vast
proportion of today's children will grow up living with only one parent.
Intended for the maximum popular consumption, the book makes its points
mostly in the anecdotal form of pseudonymous case histories. At times the
authors' valid insights are distractingly dressed in the cliches of the
"co-dependency/recovery" movement. This should nevertheless be
only a minor irritant to active divorce lawyers, whose experience independently
corroborates how valid the authors' observations are.
Treated here with great sensitivity are the adult victim's fear in approaching
adult intimate relationships, the inability to trust, the lack of a usable
"model" in the past for a lasting or a satisfying marriage, etc.
Some less predictable long-lasting effects of divorce are very usefully
treated here as well. "When Children and Parents Switch Roles"
is a discussion of a rather frightening pattern of dependency.
The authors observe that the female children of divorce are even more likely
than the males to make unwise marriage choices, have unsatisfactory marriages,
and be less reluctant to end them. They note how some of the children of
divorce are able to rationalize cutting off relations with their parents
completely so that for decades they share nothing with the aged parent but
an almost insufferable burden of guilt. Other adults do obviously irrational
things with their own lives only to demonstrate how much the divorce of
their own parents hurt them years before.
This book's writing style is evidentally designed to engage and hold the
attention of young readers. However, there is something for the lawyer here
as well. It should be quite useful to attorneys who see discouraging behavior
in their own clients and wish to know what is going on psychologically.
The book should also be of great value to the lawyer who wants to have a
few useful things to say to the divorcing client who is concerned with minimizing
the harmful impact of divorce on the family's children over the long run.
Perhaps inevitably, this book, like so many of its kind, concludes its case-history
vignettes with assurances that the sufferer got help and is now better.
Is useful to an attorney to know that a given feeling or behavior traceable
to a long-ago divorce is recognized by professionals as a pathology amenable
to treatment. This can make referral to mental-health professionals easier.
Many divorce lawyers who look over this book will want to see their
clients read it. One by-product of the bibliotherapy may be that some couples
with children are scared into permanent reconciliation.
Crouch &
Crouch home page | Family
Law Information | Family
Law Articles Index
Disclaimer: Items are not to be considered legal advice or to create
any lawyer-client relationship. Most articles include some obsolete information.
In addition, taking any legal information out of context, i.e., using it
in a different court or a subtly different kind of case, or without the
training to understand all of what it means or doing research to verify
it, usually has disastrous consequences.